Ripplings

Oct 11 2012
dresdencodak:

People can be oversensitive, sure, and I think a lot of social justice/outrage on the internet is completely overblown and mostly the product of very young people forming an identity around being offended or being offended on behalf of other people. Self-righteousness of this kind is a lazy kind of behavior done in the place of being legitimately socially conscious. Reblogging or retweeting something someone said and repeatedly calling them a bigot is not the same thing as actually raising public awareness about an issue or (ideally) working to solve it.
On the other hand, that doesn’t in any way mean there isn’t a massive amount of horrible, hurtful things being said by people everywhere, and that there isn’t a huge amount of the public mindset that has some screwed up ideas of how to treat people. Every thoughtful human being has a moral obligation to combat bigotry and all forms of intolerance, but the way you combat bigotry is extremely important. Doing it incorrectly or for the wrong reasons can make matters worse.
How do you strike the balance? Here’s my rule of thumb: Before saying something, ask yourself: am I doing this to realistically change the mind of this person or others’, or am I doing this to show how much more progressive I am? Nothing’s more venomous than attacking someone simply to assert your place in a subculture, even if it’s a subculture of activism. It’s important to always think pragmatically: if what you’re about to say/type/do seems like it’s more about making your feel better, you should rethink how you’re doing it. Lashing out or even mildly nitpicking can potentially hurt what you’re actually trying to accomplish.
The purpose of calling out hurtful language, etc is to ultimately change human behavior for the better. Anything you do without that goal in mind has the potential to be toxic. Don’t release more hate into the world, it’s the opposite of what you set out to do.

dresdencodak:

People can be oversensitive, sure, and I think a lot of social justice/outrage on the internet is completely overblown and mostly the product of very young people forming an identity around being offended or being offended on behalf of other people. Self-righteousness of this kind is a lazy kind of behavior done in the place of being legitimately socially conscious. Reblogging or retweeting something someone said and repeatedly calling them a bigot is not the same thing as actually raising public awareness about an issue or (ideally) working to solve it.

On the other hand, that doesn’t in any way mean there isn’t a massive amount of horrible, hurtful things being said by people everywhere, and that there isn’t a huge amount of the public mindset that has some screwed up ideas of how to treat people. Every thoughtful human being has a moral obligation to combat bigotry and all forms of intolerance, but the way you combat bigotry is extremely important. Doing it incorrectly or for the wrong reasons can make matters worse.

How do you strike the balance? Here’s my rule of thumb: Before saying something, ask yourself: am I doing this to realistically change the mind of this person or others’, or am I doing this to show how much more progressive I am? Nothing’s more venomous than attacking someone simply to assert your place in a subculture, even if it’s a subculture of activism. It’s important to always think pragmatically: if what you’re about to say/type/do seems like it’s more about making your feel better, you should rethink how you’re doing it. Lashing out or even mildly nitpicking can potentially hurt what you’re actually trying to accomplish.

The purpose of calling out hurtful language, etc is to ultimately change human behavior for the better. Anything you do without that goal in mind has the potential to be toxic. Don’t release more hate into the world, it’s the opposite of what you set out to do.

688 notes

  1. profanityandprophecy reblogged this from c4bl3fl4m3
  2. noooooooope reblogged this from kiwise
  3. kiwise reblogged this from dresdencodak
  4. inconvenience-of-existing reblogged this from dresdencodak and added:
    nicely put.
  5. princessmelina reblogged this from jedimasterkatara
  6. jedimasterkatara reblogged this from theabigailhobbs
  7. theabigailhobbs reblogged this from dresdencodak
  8. littlebbredbird reblogged this from kiotsukatanna
  9. littlehispanicspiders reblogged this from kiotsukatanna
  10. kiotsukatanna reblogged this from beeftony
  11. beeftony reblogged this from ryface
  12. ryface reblogged this from dresdencodak
  13. dlivr8r reblogged this from dresdencodak and added:
    Reblogging this and calling Aaron Diaz a genius is also not the same thing as actually raising public awareness about an...
  14. gabyrippling reblogged this from dresdencodak
  15. runningdroid reblogged this from dresdencodak
  16. squeemu reblogged this from proverbsforparanoids
  17. ahuttoftea reblogged this from dresdencodak and added:
    A brilliant response...vitriolic “social justice bloggers”.
  18. inarumabo reblogged this from dresdencodak and added:
    “Nothing’s more venomous than attacking someone simply to assert your place in a subculture, even if it’s a subculture...
  19. adaran7 reblogged this from dresdencodak
  20. bringinxcback reblogged this from ardentsonata
  21. eldungeon reblogged this from asteriskos
  22. hockpock reblogged this from dresdencodak
  23. postsatire reblogged this from proverbsforparanoids and added:
    This would be useful information if any of these people had any sense of self-awareness. Or could think of themselves as...
  24. thatchickwiththebook reblogged this from jazzifest
  25. proverbsforparanoids reblogged this from dresdencodak
  26. saraneththebinder reblogged this from kuwatacraft
Page 1 of 1